The 10 Most Disappointing PC Games of 2023

Whether you’re an avid gamer or just dabble in the world of PC gaming, there’s always excitement and anticipation for new game releases. However, not every game lives up to the hype. In 2023, the gaming industry saw its fair share of disappointments. From technical issues to missed expectations, these are the 12 most disappointing PC games of the year.

1. Crime Boss: Rockay City

One of the most highly anticipated games of 2023, Crime Boss: Rockay City, failed to deliver on its star-studded cast and intriguing premise. Despite featuring a lineup of Hollywood actors such as Michael Madsen, Chuck Norris, Danny Trejo, and Kim Basinger, the game fell flat with a Metacritic score of 52%.

Critics and players alike criticized Crime Boss: Rockay City for its weak storyline, poor dialogue, and lackluster voice acting. Game Informer summed it up by stating, “Crime Boss: Rockay City is proof that star power isn’t everything. In fact, it’s a reminder that a celebrity cast does nothing for a game when it’s void of anything interesting or fun to support it.”

2. Unholy

Despite its promising premise, Unholy received a lackluster reception from both players and critics, earning a 52% score on Metacritic. The game revolves around solving puzzles and uncovering the truth behind a mysterious disappearance, but it failed to deliver on its potential.

IGN criticized Unholy for not being scary enough to succeed as a horror game, clumsy controls that hindered the stealth experience, and limited enemy and puzzle variety. The lack of distinct and engaging gameplay elements left players feeling underwhelmed.

3. Testament: The Order of High-Human

Testament: The Order of High-Human attempted to blend multiple genres, including first-person action, adventure, RPG, and Metroidvania elements. However, the game’s ambitious approach ultimately backfired, resulting in a Metacritic score of 41% and a lack of any redeeming qualities.

IGN described Testament as a tedious and frustrating fantasy adventure RPG with a bland and confusing story, god-awful combat, and an overabundance of poorly executed ideas. The game’s sheer volume of bad ideas overshadowed any potential it may have had.

4. The Lord of the Rings – Gollum

Lord of the Rings: Gollum, a game centered around the iconic character Gollum, failed to live up to expectations. Technical and gameplay-related issues, including poor graphics and clunky animations, plagued the game and left players underwhelmed.

The disappointment surrounding Lord of the Rings: Gollum was further exacerbated by reports of a toxic work environment and mismanagement, leading to the closure of the studio responsible for the game’s development. The wasted potential of the beloved IP only added to the disappointment.

5. Greyhill Incident

Greyhill Incident had the potential to be an exciting horror game with a unique premise centered around an alien invasion. Unfortunately, the execution fell short, leading to a Metacritic score of 38% and a lack of recommendations from players.

Comicbook pointed out that Greyhill Incident had the potential to be a thrilling horror game but ended up feeling flavorless and disappointing. The game failed to leverage tension and aliens in a way that would have made it stand out from the crowd.

6. Atomic Heart

Atomic Heart, a first-person shooter set in an alternate reality Soviet Union, initially showed promise but failed to live up to expectations. While it attempted to capture the essence of the BioShock series, it fell short in terms of combat and progression systems, leaving players underwhelmed.

The Xbox version of Atomic Heart suffered from technical and performance issues, including frame rate problems and general gameplay bugs. Additionally, the protagonist’s dialogue and voice acting received criticism for being clichéd and delivered at odd moments.

7. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

As a franchise known for its blockbuster campaigns and addictive multiplayer, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 didn’t live up to the high standards set by its predecessors, the campaign, which was highly anticipated, felt like filler content and left fans disappointed with its short duration and reliance on recycled content.

The multiplayer experience also had its flaws, with wonky spawn points and missing popular game modes. While the game featured 16 maps, they were recycled from a previous installment, making the overall experience feel lackluster and not worth the premium price tag.

8. Cities: Skylines 2

Cities: Skylines 2, the sequel to a beloved city-building game, failed to deliver on its promise of building upon the success of its predecessor. The game lacked content that players expected from day one, such as airports, and shifted user mods from Steam Workshop to the Paradox Mods library, leaving many players disappointed.

Upon release, Cities: Skylines 2 suffered from technical issues and performance problems, with the game not meeting its ideal performance benchmarks. The game’s focus on realism came at the cost of its overall presentation and charm, leaving players underwhelmed by the lack of visual appeal.

9. Forspoken

Forspoken, a highly anticipated action RPG, had all the ingredients for success, including a talented team of writers and composers. However, the game’s development encountered numerous obstacles and revisions, resulting in a product that didn’t live up to its potential.

The open-world exploration felt lifeless, and the dialogue received criticism for being cringeworthy and out of place. Technical and performance issues further hampered the overall experience, leaving players feeling frustrated. The game’s lackluster sales led to the restructuring of the development studio responsible for its creation.

10. The Last of Us Part 1 (PC)

While the original The Last of Us game was highly regarded, the PC port of The Last of Us Part 1 faced several issues that hindered the experience. Players encountered technical problems, including visual oddities and inconsistent frame rates, which were not present in the original or remastered versions of the game.

The poorly optimized PC version also struggled to run on the Steam Deck, with lengthy load times and shader compilation issues. These problems led to negative reviews from players, highlighting the disappointment surrounding the PC release of a beloved title.


2023 had its fair share of disappointments in the world of PC gaming. From highly anticipated titles to beloved IPs, these games failed to live up to expectations due to a variety of reasons, including technical issues, poor execution, and missed opportunities. While not every game can be a hit, these 12 titles left players feeling underwhelmed and longing for more. Let’s hope that future releases will learn from these disappointments and deliver the exciting and engaging experiences that gamers crave.

Related Articles

Back to top button